Middleton Medal/Lionel Johnston Medal
| YEAR | CLUB | PLAYER |
|---|---|---|
| 2016 | North Football Club | Eddie Morgan |
| 2015 | South Football Club | Marc Purcell |
| 2014 | North Football Club | Jayden Kelly |
| 2013 | North Football Club | Heath Caldwell |
| 2012 | North Football Club | Jayden Kelly |
| 2011 | North Football Club | Jayden Kelly |
| 2010 | North Football Club | Jayden Kelly |
| 2009 | South Football Club | Alan Mackiewicz |
| 2008 | North Football Club | Codie Howard |
| 2007 | North Football Club | Codie Howard |
| 2007 | West Football Club | Tim Ferguson |
| 2006 | Central Football Club | Justin Heath |
| 2005 | North Football Club | Brendan Price |
| 2004 | North Football Club | Brett Johnson |
| 2003 | South Football Club | Anthony Murgatroyd |
| 2002 | South Football Club | Billy Dolan |
| 2001 | Central Football Club | Peter Lovell |
| 2000 | Central Football Club | Brent Rilen |
| 1999 | North Football Club | Mark Pitt |
| 1998 | South Football Club | Brad Brooks |
| 1997 | South Football Club | Anthony Murgatroyd |
| 1996 | West Football Club | Trevor Rynne |
| 1995 | North Football Club | Wayne Walker |
| 1994 | South Football Club | Brad Brooks |
| 1993 | Central Football Club | Brett Morris |
| 1992 | South Football Club | Anthony Murgatroyd |
| 1991 | North Football Club | Wayne Walker & Darren Gray |
| 1990 | West Football Club | Kerry Jay |
| 1989 | Central Football Club | Jamie Dennis |
| 1988 | North Football Club | Brian Bearman |
| 1987 | North Football Club | Steven Minnis |
| 1986 | South Football Club | Russell Ellen |
| 1985 | Central Football Club | Visko Sulicich |
| 1984 | Central Football Club | Visko Sulicich |
| 1983 | Central Football Club | Wayne Walker |
| 1982 | North Football Club | Greg Buss |
| 1981 | Central Football Club | Ross Bailey |
| 1980 | South Football Club | Peter Johns |
| 1979 | South Football Club | Gary Ford |
| 1978 | Central Football Club | Wayne Walker |
| 1977 | North Football Club | Ray Egan |
| 1976 | North Football Club | Ray Egan |
| 1975 | North Football Club | Steven Minnis |
| 1974 | North Football Club | Ray Egan |
| 1973 | North Football Club | Steven Minnis |
| 1972 | West Football Club | Peter Williams |
| 1971 | North Football Club | Ray Egan |
| 1970 | West Football Club | Geoff Burt |
| 1969 | West Football Club | Geoff Burt |
| 1968 | North Football Club | Michael Dittmar |
| 1967 | West Football Club | George Lakes |
| 1966 | North Football Club | Geoff Bourke |
| 1965 | North Football Club | Ray Egan |
| 1964 | West Football Club | Vince Gauci |
| 1963 | West Football Club | Vince Gauci |
| 1962 | South Football Club | Peter Squire |
| 1961 | South Football Club | Mick Andrich |
| 1960 | North Football Club | Rodney White |
| 1959 | North Football Club | Stan Hywood |
| 1958 | South Football Club | Phil Campbell |
| 1957 | North Football Club | Brian Wells |
| 1956 | West Football Club | Ned Rickard |
| 1955 | North Football Club | Eugene Cunningham |
| 1955 | West Football Club | Robert Tozer |
| 1954 | West Football Club | Phil Jay |
| 1953 | West Football Club | Robert Tozer |
| 1952 | West Football Club | Robert Tozer |
| 1951 | South Football Club | Harry Dickerson |
| 1950 | South Football Club | Keith Leith |
| 1949 | West Football Club | Garth Burkett |
| 1948 | West Football Club | George Merrett |
| 1947 | North Football Club | Allan Gillespie |
| 1946 | South Football Club | Owie Dinham |
| 1945 | West Football Club | Jack Pell |
| 1944 | South Football Club | William Dolan |
| 1943 | West Football Club | Lionel Williams |
| 1942 | North Football Club | Albert Strachan |
| 1941 | West Football Club | Lionel Williams |
| 1940 | South Football Club | James Brown |
| 1939 | South Football Club | Syd Crosland |
| 1938 | Central Football Club | Frank Burt |
| 1937 | North Football Club | Tom Lowe |
| 1936 | North Football Club | Tom Lowe |
| 1935 | South Football Club | Tom Parkin |
| 1934 | West Football Club | Lionel Williams |
| 1933 | Central Football Club | George Ryan |
